Page 1 of 1

Catfish suitable for my 1m. south american ciclid tank?

Posted: 27 Apr 2003, 18:49
by Kostas
Hi,

I have a 1metre south american ciclid tank with one plec* and i want to add another one south american catfish (not plec*)for eating the food leftovers.I want a catfish able to take care of themselve without being agressive towards my ciclids and my plec*.I don't want to get damaged nor to damage any of my fishes even for a single time.I give you the list of my fishes:

Aequidens rivulatus(Green Terror)
Heros Severus(Green Severum)
Liposarcus Pardalis(Common Plec*)

Please give me a list of catfishes which you are SURE that they will not get damaged and that they will not damage any of my fishes.

Thank you in advance.

Posted: 27 Apr 2003, 18:58
by Silurus
Mid-sized pimelodids such as <i>Pimelodus blochii</i> or <i>Batrachoglanis raninus</i> are good candidates.

Posted: 28 Apr 2003, 11:55
by Sid Guppy
I'm for any Pimelodus species.
Pseudopimelodus are often very immobile during the day and peaceful too, despite their piscivore habits. They can get ripped to pieces by something like a Green Terror (who can and does live up to the name).
Pimelodus are more mobile and have more character themselves; they're a bit like Synodontis in that.
Any moderately big cat from South America that behaves like a Syno will do fine, but any catfish that behaves like a dorad or callichthyd is toast with these fish. (wich rules out any Hoplo, Pseudopimelodus, Auchenipterid, Platydoras ets)
-Pimelodus blocchi, P clarias, P pictus (they're smaller but incredable FAST).
Maybe the beautiful Pimelodus maculatus or P albofasciatus? these are fairly colorful in character as well!

green terror

Posted: 28 Apr 2003, 13:25
by general-sherman
when i was much younger i put exactly the same 3 fish into the same size tank.
everything went fine.
until the green terror killed the severum and shredded the plecos fins.
those things are KILLERS!
i sold the g.t. and set-up my first s. american biotope tank with a more compatible mix of fish.

Posted: 29 Apr 2003, 09:17
by Kostas
Ohhh,i am very general-sherman. :(
I hope that this will not happens to me.
I thank you all for your help but i want to ask and something else.As i saw at the pictures pimelodids have a pair of very long barbels.Do you think that G.T. will bite them or not??Do you think that P.blocchi grows large for my 55g tank?
Thank you in advance

Posted: 29 Apr 2003, 09:33
by Silurus
Do you think that P.blocchi grows large for my 55g tank?
No. They only reach to about 10" or so.